|
So my colleagues and I recently published a tongue
in cheek commentary poking fun at the recent explosion of the
ecological niche modeling (ENM) field using bigfoot data. Really it was
Mike's idea, and we played around with it at the last Evolution
meeting, where it seemed like 90% of the presentations made use in some
way of ENMs (mine included). Somewhat unexpectedly, the paper received
a fairly substantial response from the press (including Nature, New
Scientist, a Czech newspaper, and a number of sciblogs) which was
pretty fun! So I thought I'd put up a set of links to some of the better articles. Our
main intention with this paper was not to prove/disprove bigfoot, or to
disparage the technology or applications of niche modeling in any way.
We were only urging people who might want to use the method to pay
close attention to the data points they use. We really have no stance
on the existence of bigfoot, except that given the lack of tangible
evidence we are forced towards skepticism. But to clarify for the
bigfoot believers, we did not consider the sighting data set we
used for modeling questionable because of our opinions on the
existence/non-existence of the beast, but because of the lack of
physical specimens to back up these records. Our goal was simply to
encourage careful specimen-level scrutiny of public biodiversity data
from museum collections, etc before application in niche modeling or
any other scientific endeavor. In my opinion, if people are inclined to
believe that the bigfoot data is valid, our maps are a valuable
resource for planning future expeditions, as ENMs have proven useful
for identifying new populations of species in areas where they have
previously not been observed. As for myself, I am open minded, but
unitil I see some tangible evidence, our black bear comparison is too
striking to ignore. Lozier J. D., Aniello P., Hickerson M. J. (2009) Predicting the distribution of Sasquatch in western North
America: anything goes with ecological niche modeling. Journal of
Biogeography, online early. Nature (July 7, 2009) Bigfoot study highlights habitat modeling flaws.
Nature Podcast (July 9, 2009). New Scientist (July 10, 2009) Bigfoot's Favorite Haunts Revealed. The Missoulian (July 2009). Researcher maps Sasquacth sightings to display problems with new technology. LIDOVÉ NOVINY (12. srpna 2009). Kde je doma sněžný muž. John Hawks Weblog (July 3, 2009) Bigfoot biogeography. The Evilutionary Biologist (July 2, 2009) Bigfoot of Mistaken Identity? i'm a chordata! urochordata! (July 1, 2009) Mapping the Sasquatch. Myrmecos Blog (July 2, 2009) Big changes afoot for Sasquatch. World of Weird Things (July 8,2009) where the sasquatches roam... Tonic (July 7, 2009) Sasquatch out for bad data. Standard Deviations from the Beaten Path (July 8, 2009) Publishing Cryptozoology (Legitimately). |